11 Ways To Determine If A Worker Is An Employee (W-2) Or Independent Contractor (1099 NEC) 

11 Ways To Determine If A Worker Is An Employee (W-2) Or Independent Contractor (1099 NEC)

Aug 13, 2021

11 Ways To Determine If A Worker Is An Employee (W-2) Or Independent Contractor (1099 NEC).png

When you hire Independent Contractors, you want to make sure you are avoiding misclassification. A business that classifies its employee as an Independent Contractor but fails to meet all the regulatory requirements can be subject to a government tax audit or lawsuits.

According to the Harvard Business Review, the use of Independent Contractors has increased by 40% in the last decade. According to the Labor Department, so many employees are misclassified because companies are not knowledgeable about how to classify their employees according to labor and workplace laws. The issue of misclassification of Independent Contractors has been around for a while. According to the IRS, they primarily view workers as Independent Contractors when they should be classified as W-2 Employees.

In every business, you have your regular W-2 employees, and the company will take out payroll taxes and pay that amount to the IRS for each pay period. At the end of the year, the employee will receive their W-2 and will then pay additional taxes to the government or receive a refund. 

However, when a business classifies an employee as an Independent Contractor (IC), payroll taxes are a little different. The business pays the IC a gross amount, and then the IC is responsible for making their own tax deposits to the IRS. The company is responsible for reporting payments made to the IC to the government. This will be done using the form 1099 NEC at the end of the year with copies sent to the recipient, the Federal government, and the States that require 1099 NEC reporting.

The IRS has categorized three groups that will help determine if an employee is a W-2 or an Independent Contractor.

  • Behavioral Control: Does a company control what the worker does and how they do their job?
  • Financial Control: How is the worker paid? Do they do expense reimbursement?
  • Type of Relationship: Are there written contracts or employee-type benefits?

According to the IRS and court precedent, the following items indicate that a worker is an employee:

  • Level Of Instruction: If the company directs when, where, and how work is done, this control indicates a possible employment relationship.
  • Degree of Business Integration: Workers whose services are integrated into business operations or significantly affect business success are likely to be considered employees. 
  • Services Rendered Personally: Companies that insist on a particular person performing the work assert a degree of control that suggests an employment relationship. 
  • Set Hours Of Work: People whose hours or days of work are dictated by a company are apt to qualify as its employees. 
  • Full-time Required: Full-time work gives a company control over most of a person's time, which supports a finding of an employment relationship. 
  • Furnishing Tools and Materials: Workers who perform most of their work using company-provided equipment, tools, and materials are more likely to be considered employees. 

According to the IRS and court precedent, the following items indicate that a worker is a contractor:

  • Investment In Facilities: Independent contractors typically invest in and maintain their own work facilities.
  • Realization Of Profit Or Loss: A worker who can realize a profit or suffer a loss providing the services is generally an independent contractor.
  • Working For More Than One Firm At A Time: People who simultaneously provide services for several unrelated companies are likely to qualify as independent contractors. 
  • Making Service Available To The General Public: If a worker makes his or her services available to the public on a regular and consistent basis, that indicates independent contractor status.
  • Hiring, Supervision, & Paying Assistants: If the worker hires and supervises others under a contract pursuant to which the worker agrees to provide material and labor and is only responsible for the result, this indicates independent contractor status.

For additional information about the 1099 NEC click here. To see the complete list of IRS and court precedents, click here.

Tags: 1099 NEC, W-2

Category List

Tag List

Fraud (2)
Payroll Software (6)
Paycard (1)
Initiatives (1)
2020 IRS Form W-2 (2)
Sick Leave (1)
Solutions (2)
Social Security Wage Base (2)
Small Business (2)
IRS 1099 NEC Form (2)
Electronic W-2 (1)
Web Forms (1)
1095-B (2)
Reporting (1)
IRS Form W-2 (6)
Certified Payroll Reports (1)
Accountant Shortage (1)
Human Resource (1)
B-Notice (2)
CIO Review (3)
ACA e-filing (3)
1099-INT (1)
Sage 300 CRE (1)
IRS Form 941 (3)
Workplace Efficiencies (1)
payroll reporting changes (2)
Aatrix eFile (8)
Windows (3)
Millennials (2)
CP2100 (3)
Dependent Care (1)
1099-PATR (1)
cyber attacks (1)
IRS Form 941 & 940 changes (3)
Social Security Tax Deferral (1)
Top Software (1)
Withholding (2)
TIN Matching (4)
IRS Form W-3C (1)
SOC3 (2)
Sage Summit (2)
SSA (2)
Payroll Tax Relief (1)
Helpful Hints (1)
HSA (1)
Tax Return (1)
Quarterly Reports (1)
IRS Form 1099 NEC (3)
Payroll Reports (16)
Employee Documentation (1)
SOC2 (4)
Reports (1)
eFile (6)
IRS (5)
ACA eFiling (3)
remote office (2)
ACA Reporting (4)
CIO (3)
Top 10 (3)
American Rescue Plan (1)
Payroll Solution (6)
Secure eFiling (2)
Accounting Solutions Provider (2)
IRS Form 7200 (1)
Solution (3)
Child Tax Credit (2)
Technology (3)
eFiling Thresholds (2)
w-4 (2)
The Families First Coronavirus Response Act (1)
Assessment (4)
Payroll Tax (3)
IRS Forms (1)
Improvements (1)
1095-C (2)
Review (2)
I-9 (2)
Tax Identification Number Verification (2)
Tax Identification Number (2)
State Payroll Reports (3)
EEO-1 (3)
1099-G (4)
Corrections (1)
Top 100 (2)
Venmo (1)
e-Filing (1)
Retirement Contribution Limits (1)
Paycheck (2)
Technology Companies (2)
Recruiting & Retention (4)
OEM Payroll (2)
IRS Form 941 Changes (2)
SMBs (1)
New Hire Reporting (3)
Ultimate Payroll (1)
Infrastructure (1)
1099-MISC (1)
Forms (1)
Standard Mileage Rate (1)
workplace dynamics (2)
1094-C (2)
Payroll Compliance (4)
Safe eFiling (1)
Aatrix (6)
irstaxtip (1)
Future (1)
IRS 7200 Tax Form (1)
Social Security Withholding (3)
work from home (1)
W-2 (8)
Cryptocurrency (2)
Coronavirus Aid (2)
unemployment (5)
1099-K (2)
Payroll (17)
Affordable Care Act (3)
Sponsorship (1)
Year-End Deadlines (2)
employee retention (4)
eFiling (3)
ACA Compliance (3)
Payments (1)
SSA Notice (2)
Aatrix Software (9)
e-File (1)
Compliance (5)
TIN Matching Services (4)
Economic Security Act (1)
Rebranding (1)
CA Pay Data Report (1)
State (1)
Families First Coronavirus Response Act (1)
Top 50 (1)
Form 941 (1)
Sage (1)
New Logo (1)
Tax Payments (1)
Sage Summit 2015 (1)
1099 TIN Matching (4)
1099 NEC (5)
Business Travel (1)
Accounting Solutions (2)
CV Magazine (1)
Enterprise (2)
Filing (1)
Employee Tax Credits (1)
ACA (6)
Federal (1)
HFSA (1)
Aatrix Software, Inc. (5)
Staff (1)
Cloud (1)
Payroll Tax Notice (2)
TUG (1)
Coronavirus (2)
Employee Retention Credit (2)
Travel Expenses (1)
IRS Notice (2)
1095 (4)
Security (5)
Innovation (2)
1099 (9)
Medicare Tax (1)
Sage Solutions (1)
Sage Summit 2014 (1)
IRS 941 Form (2)
Travel During Covid (1)
Virtual Currency (1)
Growth (1)
Medical Leave (1)
Tax (2)
Federal Payroll Reports (2)
Social Security Number Verification (3)
1094-B (2)
1099 G (1)
HR (1)
941 (5)
COVID-19 (8)
Sage Solutions Provider (1)
CV Technology Innovator Awards (1)
IRS Tax Forms (2)
ACA 1095 C&B requirements (2)
Mac (1)
Company Of The Year (1)
vaccine (2)
Federal Taxes (1)
IRS Form 1099 (3)
IRS 7200 Form (1)
Employee Travel (1)
Payroll Taxes (1)
covid (2)
Labor Shortage (1)
Paycheck Protection Program (1)
941-X (1)
Payroll Tax Forms (3)
Per Diem (1)
PTO Payout (1)
Paypal (1)
Awards (1)
Payroll Tax Reporting (8)
Payroll Reporting (13)
IRS Notice 931 (1)

Tag Cloud

InfrastructureTechnology CompaniesMacSolutionSSA NoticeAccounting SolutionsPer DiemRetirement Contribution Limitsworkplace dynamicsCoronavirusAatrix SoftwareSage Summit 2014Tax ReturnPayroll ComplianceSocial Security Number VerificationEmployee Retention CreditCOVID-19Payroll Tax ReliefMillennialsunemploymentSocial Security WithholdingVenmoAatrixSecure eFilingImprovementsIRS Form W-3CEFTPSeFiling1099-PATRHuman ResourceAmerican Rescue PlanThe Families First Coronavirus Response ActSage 300 CREWindowsSolutionsIRS FormsIRS Tax FormsYear-End DeadlinesOEM PayrollWorkplace Efficiencies1099 NECTop 100Cloud1099-MISCEmployee TravelSage SummitIRS Form 941 & 940 changesPayroll SolutionSMBsCV MagazinePayroll ReportingStandard Mileage RateIRS Form 7200Payroll Tax FormsSage1094-CPaycardirstaxtipACA ReportingCorrectionsCIOMedical LeaveAatrix Software, Inc.AwardsReportsNew LogoFederalChild Tax CreditForm 941e-FilingCP2100Social Security Tax DeferralEEO-1PaypalEmployee DocumentationHIPAACoronavirus AidTravel ExpensesRebrandingSage Solutions ProviderIRS Notice 931Payroll ReportsCIO ReviewInitiativesTop 10Families First Coronavirus Response ActEnterpriseGrowthLabor ShortageIRS Form 941CryptocurrencySage Summit 2015Dependent CareTIN MatchingIRS Form 1099CA Pay Data Report941Company Of The YearIRS Form 1099 NECWeb Forms1099 TIN Matching2020 IRS Form W-2FormsCertified Payroll ReportsACA ComplianceReportingPTO PayoutSocial Security Wage BaseVirtual CurrencyIRSPayrollHSASick LeaveQuarterly ReportsAatrix eFileTax Identification Number Verificationcyber attacksEconomic Security ActSafe eFilingFederal Payroll ReportsSage SolutionsTUGPayroll TaxesAssessmentState Payroll ReportsI-9Paycheck1095-CPayroll Tax NoticeTop 50employee retention1095Small Business1099-INT1099B-NoticeIRS 7200 Formwork from homeHFSAIRS 7200 Tax FormFilingIRS Form 941 ChangesFederal TaxesIRS 1099 NEC Form1094-BSOC2SponsorshipPayroll TaxSecurityTravel During CovidIRS NoticeACA 1095 C&B requirementsHRpayroll reporting changesTop SoftwareElectronic W-2w-41099-KPayroll Tax ReportingUltimate PayrollTechnologyComplianceSOC3SSA1095-B1099-GACA e-filingTaxe-FileAffordable Care ActRecruiting & Retentionremote office1099 GWithholdingACA eFilingPaycheck Protection ProgramTIN Matching ServicesTax PaymentseFileMedicare TaxInnovationNew Hire ReportingStaffeFiling ThresholdsIRS 941 FormIRS Form W-2vaccineAccountant ShortageACAPaymentsStateAccounting Solutions ProviderFutureW-2Helpful HintsBusiness Travel941-XcovidPayroll SoftwareTax Identification NumberReviewCV Technology Innovator AwardsEmployee Tax CreditsFraud